bungee vs. catapult
#1

Seems that people prefer bungees vs catapult, but I wonder if catapult is not more reliable.
On the other hand, we know that the correct bungee tension must be about 5 times the model weight; but what for catapults, should be also 5 times?
On the other hand, we know that the correct bungee tension must be about 5 times the model weight; but what for catapults, should be also 5 times?
#2
Super Contributor
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 1,957

I have never seen a catapult. But, I assume they are not as gentle to the planes structure as a bungee?
I have seen 50' bungees for the gliders. They are operated by a guy in a golf cart for retrieve and launch.
I have seen 50' bungees for the gliders. They are operated by a guy in a golf cart for retrieve and launch.
He is fully protected all the time. Neat.
#5

I know a guy who is a bit crazy in his old age, as he did too many drugs in his youth and scrambled his brains. He got banned from operating the winch on real life gliders as he couldn't take his foot off the pedal because his leg cramped up.
#6
Member
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 39

My catapult uses two 1/2" x36 poplar dowels 9" apart in a section of 2x4 pine. LARGE nails anchor it. A 20' length of small size hi-start rubber with an anchor ring on one end and a 10' twine string with a ring at the other end comprise the basic launch device.A second ring is located far enough forward on the string to let the plane set on the catapult with-out the tail feathers touching the base. The catapult is angled 10 degrees up.
The end ring is placed in a slot in the 2x4 that has a loose fitting vertical pull pin.This is servo actuated with a second receiver/battery that I trip with the retract switch on my transmitter when ready to launch.
The hook is located just ahead of the C/G and the line tension is set at 8-10 # for a GWS Spitfire.
The plane is off in a literal blur!!! I throttle up after it comes off the line.
I am an old guy with a torn shoulder joint,thus the catapult. A friend has a duplicate for an E-powered Hellcat that couldn't be launched with a good shoulder.
FWIW. art
The end ring is placed in a slot in the 2x4 that has a loose fitting vertical pull pin.This is servo actuated with a second receiver/battery that I trip with the retract switch on my transmitter when ready to launch.
The hook is located just ahead of the C/G and the line tension is set at 8-10 # for a GWS Spitfire.
The plane is off in a literal blur!!! I throttle up after it comes off the line.
I am an old guy with a torn shoulder joint,thus the catapult. A friend has a duplicate for an E-powered Hellcat that couldn't be launched with a good shoulder.
FWIW. art
#9

I am finishing one and I will upload the plans these days.
Now let me tell you, when it comes to launching low wing models what I have been doing so far is that I put three small pieces of tirplay under the wing as to form a tirangle, two aligned with the c.g. for the middlefinger and thumb and one behind for the index, so I grasp it as a Bowling ball, and so far I have launched my planes succesfully, and they are so small that they go unnoticed, but of course a catapult is more convenient although more cumbersome.
In the photos you can see this configuration for a GWS Corsair
Now let me tell you, when it comes to launching low wing models what I have been doing so far is that I put three small pieces of tirplay under the wing as to form a tirangle, two aligned with the c.g. for the middlefinger and thumb and one behind for the index, so I grasp it as a Bowling ball, and so far I have launched my planes succesfully, and they are so small that they go unnoticed, but of course a catapult is more convenient although more cumbersome.
In the photos you can see this configuration for a GWS Corsair
#13
Savage Light Industries
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 6

We replaced the bungee cord with 3/8" Dripped Mandrel Latex (DML). DML is IMHO the best material to use for catapults or bungees. We also bungee launched these jets, again using DML.
We also changed to larger rollers on the front to accomidate the larger diameter of the DML, as well as added a custom rear pulley system and improved the latching lever.
The bungee pulls the models to a much higher speed than the catapult, but the catpult is much more portable. The catapult is consistant, giving exactly the same toss every time. There is no worry about the infamous Bungee Death Roll with the catapult.
Mostly I think it depends on your needs. Bungees are nearly impossible to use with tractor propeller models. The combat catapults, use special cradles to hold the wings for launching.
Daren
#14
Savage Light Industries
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 6
#16
Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 265

Have been launching my T-33 via bungee since 99; during warm weather only – bungee (latex tube) doesn’t do well when its cold. That’s a lot missed flying time here in the upper Midwest; and its nice to belly flop on snow.
Inspired by edfrules, I built and now have successfully launched my T-33 via an Air Catapult!
Details can be found here: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=524127 .
Sorry no video of the T-33 being launched, but here a test with a 7lb-13oz plank @ 80 & 100psi: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=527873 .
Inspired by edfrules, I built and now have successfully launched my T-33 via an Air Catapult!
Details can be found here: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=524127 .
Sorry no video of the T-33 being launched, but here a test with a 7lb-13oz plank @ 80 & 100psi: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=527873 .
#18
Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 265
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Tucson Don
General Electric Discussions
2
08-16-2006 09:44 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)